Dec 10, 2022
A close look at the rule of thirds and the golden ratio. What do they have in common? What's their history? Let’s have a closer look at the history of these so-called rules to get a better understanding.
The rule of thirds is the first thing that is taught about composition in photography. It seems to have some similarities with the golden ratio, but in reality, it’s something completely different. Let’s have a closer look at the history of these so-called rules to get a better understanding.
The rule of thirds is quite a simple rule. Divide the image in nine equal parts, by drawing two horizontal and two vertical lines at thirds from the edges. Place your subject on one of the lines or at the intersection of the lines, and you’re done. Sort of.
Although this can help to achieve an acceptable composition in some situations, the rule of thirds was never intended that way. In fact, the origin has absolutely nothing to do with drawing lines at thirds of the image. At first look, the similarity with the golden ratio does make it seem the two are related. Nothing is further from the truth. Let me explain why by diving into history.
The Golden Ratio, Fibonacci, and Archimedes
The golden ratio is an invention of mathematicians. It had nothing to do with composition in paintings. A Greek called Euclid, who lived somewhere around 400 BC, found out that the division of a line according to a certain ratio can go on indefinitely. This ratio is an irrational number, which means it cannot be written down as a natural fraction.
This irrational number is the golden ratio. The number is 1.618 followed by an infinite amount of digits, and the Greek letter for it is Phi.
The golden ratio. It's all about playing with numbers. The number is quite special. It cannot be written as a natural fraction.
It took 16 centuries before Leonardo of Pisa came up with a sequence of numbers that was pretty special. Every number was the sum of the previous two, and the sequence was infinite. This sequence of numbers was named after his nickname: the Fibonacci sequence.
Astronomer Johannes Kepler finally discovered the link between the golden ratio and the Fibonacci sequence. He found out how the division between a Fibonacci number by the previous number in the sequence would approach the golden ratio with increasing accuracy.
The well know square based on the golden ratio. The Fibonacci sequence numbers are added. It all fits like a glove.
Everyone knows about Archimedes. He cried out "eureka" when discovering how to find out if the golden crown of King Hiëro of Syracuse was a fake or not. But Archimedes was also obsessed with spirals. One of the spirals he made was the Spirabilis Mirabilis, based on the golden ratio. Today we know this spiral better by the name Fibonacci Spiral (we’re sorry about that, Archimedes).
Archimedes made the spiral, but we name it after Fibonacci.
Luca Pacioli and the Golden Ratio for Composition
We seem to find a lot of examples in nature where the golden ratio and Fibonacci spiral are present. Of course, we have a habit of looking at those similarities and ignoring everything that doesn’t have the similarity. Nevertheless, the golden ratio is something that often appears in things growing in nature, like the distribution of leaves on a stem or the seeds in a sunflower.
Perhaps it was because of this that an Italian monk named Luca Pacioli came up with a common rule for composition. Somewhere between the 15th and 16th century, he claimed how a painting would become most realistic when the composition was made by mathematical rules. The golden ratio was chosen for this.
Windmills at Wijk bij Duurstede from the painter Jacob van Ruisdael with the Fibonacci spiral.(public domain, Creative Commons)
Today, we try to see the golden ratio in everything that has been built, drawn, or painted. We search for the golden ratio in buildings like the Parthenon, Pyramids, and even modern buildings. We draw the Fibonacci spiral over well-known paintings like the Mona Lisa by Leonardo da Vinci or the Girl with a Pearl Earring by Johannes Vermeer.
The Fibonacci Spiral projected over the paintings of the Mona Lisa by Leonardo da Vinci (public domain, Creative Commons) and the Girl With a Pearl Earring by Johannes Vermeer (public domain, Creative Commons).
The Rule of Thirds
For the origin of the rule of thirds, we have to travel in time towards 1797. At that time, a certain Sir Joshua Reynolds taught at the Royal Academy of Arts in London, mentioning in his discourses how a painting works best when the use of light and dark has a ratio of approximately 1/3:2/3.
There was never any mentioning of a rule of thirds, until an English painter called John Thomas Smith came up with the rule after reading the discourses of Sir Joshua Reynolds. He took the 1/3:2/3 division even further and said it should be used for everything in a composition.
Remarks on Rural Scenery from 1797 by John Thomas Smith that has the first known mention of the rule of thirds. (Project Gutenberg)
There were a lot of people who don’t like the rule of thirds, even back then. A certain George Fields wrote about the downsides of the rule of thirds in 1845, saying how the use of the rule would produce boring and monotonous images.
Chromatics: Or the Analogy, Harmony, and Philosophy of Colours by George Field, written in 1845 with comments about the use of the rule of thirds. (Project Gutenburg, 2014)
Today, the rule of thirds has been reduced to a bunch of lines in a photo. You should place the subject on one of the lines or at the intersections of those lines. This would give the image a lot of suspense and energy. Not everyone agrees, for obvious reasons. The original idea behind the rule of thirds, the way how light and dark in an image should be distributed, is lost and forgotten.
Composition with the rule of thirds. I think it works quite well. But it has nothing to do with the original concept of the rule.
Using the Rule of Thirds or the Golden Ratio
Back to modern times again. Most photographers have learned to use the rule of thirds. I believe it does work on some occasions. But perhaps it’s wiser to use the lines for the distribution of the subject in the frame. It doesn’t have to be on the thirds at all, especially if you end up with the other two thirds being almost empty. Balance and visual flow in an image are much more important.
The rule of thirds in a 5:4 aspect ratio. It seems to work quite nicely because the distribution of elements is in balance.
Using something like the golden ratio works much better for a lot of occasions, I think. The Fibonacci spiral can help find a visual flow through the image. There is one problem, though. Because we often visualize these rules by using the crop tool in software like Lightroom and Photoshop, we look at the lines without realizing the composition doesn’t follow the golden ratio at all.
The golden ratio projected over the 5:4 aspect ratio. It can't fill the frame completely.
Those crop tools project the rules inside the aspect ratio of the image itself. This can be 3:2, 4:3, or 5:4, to name a few. But this way, you’re not looking at the lines of a golden ratio anymore, because that has an aspect ratio 1.618:1. So, you may think you’re using it, but you're not. On the other hand, the rule of thirds is independent of the aspect ratio of an image.
It’s nice to have all these rules, and I find it important to know about its origin to understand why you should use it or not. It also illustrates that using these rules to the letter is often not very artistic. You might end up being more of a mathematician instead of a photographer.
I think it’s much wiser to find balance in a photo. Avoid distractions and use lines and curves to connect the elements in your composition. You might be surprised how often it will turn out to have a golden ratio after all or even a rule of thirds.
I haven't followed any composition rule while taking this photo. I just filled the frame in a way that was pleasing. But it fits the rule of thirds, as it turns out.
There are many other ways of achieving a composition. You can use the rule of odds, negative space, or the gestalt principle. How do you build the composition for your photos? Do you use the rule of thirds, golden ratio, or another rule? Please share your preferred way in the comments below.
Read the original article here.